Civics Library Of The Missouri Bar

It's My Body

Setting:    High School classroom during a meeting for winter sports

Players:   Girls' basketball coach--Coach Champ,

                Boys' basketball coach--Coach Winner,

                Players--Jack and Jill

 

Coach Champ:  All of you players need to know that at any time we can require you to give us a urine sample.

Jack:  No way!  That is an invasion of our privacy.

Coach Winner:  The United States Supreme Court says we can do it and we will. 

Jill:  Why are you  doing this? 

Coach Champ:  To test for drug use among the athletes. 

Jack:  I didn't think we had a drug problem in this school 

Coach Winner:  We don't, but we are going to test so we can keep drugs out. 

Jill:  I don't think the United States Supreme Court allows you to do that. 

Coach Champ:  The school lawyers, Joanie Cochran and Mark Clark, say we can legally do this. 

Jack:  Those two got their law degrees by correspondence courses.

                                                           ******************* 

1.  Who's right, the coaches or the students?    See Vernonia v. Acton, 115 Supreme Court Reporter, Page 2386. 

2.  Additional activity:  Have the students read the Vernonia decision and list the necessary criteria for allowing the urine testing.